The term “cruelty-free” is unregulated. This means that brands aren’t breaking the law by calling themselves cruelty-free, even if they test on animals.
Many beauty brands try to mislead us this way.
If a “cruelty-free” claim isn’t enough, how can we find out if brands are truly cruelty-free? As caring beauty lovers, we’ve developed a solid system to find out the truth. We call it the Cruelty Free 5.
The Cruelty-Free 5 are the five stages at which animal testing can occur. If a brand can confirm that they pass these stages, we can consider them cruelty-free.
At Cruelty-Free Kitty, these are the questions we ask all brands:
- Does your brand test on animals, for either finished products or ingredients?
- Do your suppliers test on animals? How do you ensure this?
- Do any third-parties test on animals on your behalf?
- Do you test on animals where required by law?
- In which countries are your products sold (excluding online sales)?
Brands must answer these questions with a resounding “no”, as well as confirm that their products aren’t sold in mainland China. This is because most cosmetics have to be tested on animals in order to be sold there, and they continue to be at risk of animal testing once they’re on the shelves.
Let’s take a closer look at the Cruelty-Free 5.
The brand itself does not engage in animals testing, either for finished products or ingredients.
Most brands no longer test on animals themselves, which is why it can be deceptive when brands claim to be “cruelty-free”. It’s important for brands to confirm that they themselves don’t perform any animal testing, but we need to dig deeper.
Their suppliers don’t engage in animals testing, either for finished products, raw materials, or ingredients.
Suppliers sell products or ingredients to the brand. Some suppliers do test on animals, so it’s important to ask this question. Watch out for brands who claim that their ingredients aren’t tested on animals, yet can’t confirm if their suppliers test on animals. In order to be cruelty-free, a brand must confirm that their suppliers don’t engage in animal testing.
No third-parties test on animals on their behalf.
A third-party is an outside company or entity, which can test their finished products or ingredients on their behalf. A third-party doesn’t have to be hired by the brand. If they claim that third-parties may test their products on animals, for example in mainland China, the brand is not truly cruelty-free.
They don’t test on animals when it’s required by law.
Many brands claim not to test on animals at any point, “unless required by law”. A brand that’s truly cruelty-free doesn’t test on animals at all. No exceptions. If a brand makes an exception where required by law, it most likely means that they had to pay for their products to be tested on animals in mainland China.
They don’t sell cosmetics in stores in mainland China.
It’s important to ask brands where their products are sold, since some might try to be sneaky. We ask them where their products are sold in stores, excluding online sales. If the company sells cosmetics in stores in mainland China, we can’t consider it to be cruelty-free. This excludes Hong Kong, which is not part of mainland China.
To Sum It Up
Next time you’re trying to find out if a brand is truly cruelty-free, simply ask them these 5 questions. Brands that are truly transparent and cruelty-free will respond with clear answers.
If they skip questions or follow up with a short animal testing policy, watch out. You might not be dealing with a cruelty-free company.