Two concealers. But only one winner. (insert dramatic music) Well, not really! They each serve different purposes, and chances are that only one of them is better suited for YOUR skin.

I’m going to ramble a little bit about each product, so please click here to jump straight to the conclusion if you want to skip that!


Shades

Before I start, you should know that I have the lightest shades in both. Coverage and consistency might be slightly different in the lighter shades in my experience, but there shouldn’t be any major differences.

nars-chantilly-urban-decay-fair-neutral

As to how the shades compare, they’re very very close. Chantilly is quite warm/yellow. Fair Neutral is slightly more cool/pink than Chantilly, and I would say it’s a true neutral.


1. NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

narss

Available here at Sephora in 10 shades. $29 for 0.22oz.

This one’s described as “A creamy concealer with hydrating, multiaction skin care benefits and light diffusing technology to create a softer, smoother complexion.”

It’s indeed very creamy. It covers anything dry without flaking. I have combination skin and have had no problems when it comes to my dry patches.

As for the “light diffusing technology”, I’d say that’s bull. The finish is actually on the matte side, which I like. If you’re using this concealer to cover blemishes, you don’t want this concealer to diffuse light and attract more attention to spots and bumps regardless.

nars-radiant-creamy-concealer

“Hydrating and luxuriously smooth, it layers lightly for buildable medium-to-full coverage and a natural luminous finish.”

While it’s hydrating to some degree, those with dry skin might not like wearing this one as an undereye concealer. It’s not as luminous as claimed and dries fairly matte.

Although it’s recommended for all skin types by NARS, those with very dry skin might want to opt for the Naked Skin instead. If you’re prone to creasing, this one crease a bit more than the Naked Skin (but has higher coverage).

About the coverage, it’s pretty full coverage. One swipe over a blemish and it’s gone.

Application-wise, we’re dealing with a classic doe foot applicator. I only mention this because the Naked Skin Concealer has a slightly different applicator (pics are below).


2. Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer

udd

Available here at Sephora in 11 shades. $28 for 0.16oz.

It’s described as “An innovative, high-coverage concealer that provides buildable, weightless coverage and leaves an invisible, Naked Skin finish.”

I have to address the “high coverage” claim first. This concealer to me provides medium coverage. Nothing less, but certainly nothing more. I was disappointed by the coverage, and I can’t use it to cover up blemishes.

That being said, it does feel very lightweight for the medium coverage it provides. It’s great for dry skin and it’s easier to blend than the NARS. It’s also not cakey at all, if cakeyness really puts you off.

urban-decay-naked-skin-concealer

“It’s easily blendable and buildable, giving you even coverage with a luminous, demi-matte finish. Ultra-lightweight, this high-tech liquid formula never settles into fine lines, and it melds on for a no makeup look while full coverage in an instant. “

The finish really is luminous and demi-matte. Another reason why I wouldn’t use it on blemishes.

It also settles into fine lines less than the NARS one, but it’s certainly not as full coverage.

“This concealer is enriched with Matrixyl 3000, which contains peptides to support the skin’s youthful appearance and elasticity, and Japanese green tea revitalizes and helps reduce the look of fine lines.”

I don’t know how potent these ingredients will be in such small amount, especially considering that we apply concealer on top of moisturizer, primer, and foundation (or more). This concealer is silicone-based, and contains glycerin as well.

The applicator is more of a paddle shape. It’s a minor detail, but I find that it works better under the eyes and picks up more product in one shot.


Bottom Line

The NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer gives you more coverage compared to the Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer.

It covers blemishes and very dark circles well. It has a slightly thicker and drier consistency, and the finish is less luminous.

It’s best for normal to oily skin.

If you’re looking for a concealer to cover up spots and blemishes, go for this one.

The Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer has a luminous finish and blends seamlessly.

It provides slignthly less coverage than the NARS, but it won’t crease as much and it’s lightweight and more hydrating.

It’s better suited if you have normal to dry skin.

If you’ll only use this concealer under your eyes, go for this one. It blends nicely, has a luminous finish, and won’t crease.

Also note that you’re getting slightly more product with the Radiant Creamy Concealer for about the same price (0.22oz for $29 as opposed to 0.16oz for $28).

Which one would you pick?

Cruelty-free made simple!

Download the full list of cruelty-free brands in my 10-page guide, Cruelty-Free Made Simple. Enter your name and email below to get it in your inbox.

Suzana Rose
By Suzana Rose|
Suzana is the founder of Cruelty-Free Kitty. She believes in ethical businesses and wants to see a global ban on animal testing. She loves cats, debunking myths, and shoegaze music.